[25] The 2007 team won the South, Group III state sectional championship with a 62-6 win against Seneca High School.

In 2019, the wrestling team defeated Clearview Regional High School 47-16 in the South Jersey Group IV championship.

[33] In 2012 the softball team won the South Jersey Group III state sectional championship with a 2-0 win against Central Regional High School.

[38][39] The 2004 team repeated as sectional champions, defeating Ocean City High School again in the tournament final by a score of 1-0.

[44] The girls' track team won the Group III state indoor relay championship in 2007 (as co-champion with Ridge High School), 2013 (co-champion with Winslow Township High School) and 2014; the boys' team won the indoor relay title in 2014, 2015 and 2020.

[45] The boys' tennis team won the 2007 South Jersey Group III state sectional championship with a 4-1 win over Cumberland Regional High School.

[citation needed] The boys' basketball team won the South Jersey Group III championship for three straight years from 2009 to 2011.

The school's marching band achieved 3rd place in 2006 for their show, Jesus Christ Superstar, though outscoring their championship year by 5 points.

From October to November 2011, the Kingsway Dragon Marching Band became Central New Jersey and State Champions under grouping of IA under the direction of Nicholas Kline.

In November 2011, they placed second at Nationals held in Allentown, PA. Their show was based on the Broadway musical, Jekyll & Hyde.

The school's marching band won the USBands Group II A national championship in 2015 with their program Voodoo in the Bayou.