She endured a knee injury in a match against Virginia Tech on October 31 which prevented her from playing the remainder of the season.

That September she was named the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) Co-Offensive Player Of The Week while playing as a defender and scoring twice against Virginia Tech.

[8] McNabb made her debut for the Wave on the club's inaugural match, a 1–1 draw against Angel City FC on March 19, 2022.

[10] During the Challenge Cup and parts of the 2022 season, McNabb played as a defensive midfielder, but she eventually ended back up in her more natural position of left-back.

[10] McNabb's lone goal of the season occurred on June 17, 2023, in a match against rivals Angel City FC.

McNabb opened the scoring in the 57th minute with a left-footed strike through the legs of defender Ali Riley and into the back of the net.

[18] In stoppage time, McNabb was issued a red card after an altercation with Reign player and former teammate Jess Fishlock.

[19][20] McNabb's red card suspension rendered her unavailable for the Wave's next fixture, a match against the Utah Royals on May 8.