Madison's main rivals are Perry, Geneva, Riverside, and Chardon High Schools.

They include, for boys, golf, soccer, Cross Country, basketball, swimming, wrestling, baseball, football, track and field, tennis, and cheerleading.

As it is with most high schools, girls at Madison also have the opportunity to engage in many sports, which include tennis, volleyball, soccer, Cross Country, basketball, swimming, softball, track and field, golf, and cheerleading.

The Blue Streaks softball team had a tremendous run in the OHSAA tournament in the 2016-2017 school year.

The ladies won a District title and came second in the Western Reserve Conference.