Ramya Ragupathi, Naresh's ex-wife, filed a plea to prevent the film's release and to stop its distribution, claiming that it portrays her in a negative way.

[19][20] Neeshita Nyayapati of The Times of India gave it 2.5 out of 5 stars and wrote, "Malli Pelli is the tale of two consenting adults who happen to fall in love and face judgement from society.

"[21] Abhilasha Cherukuri of Cinema Express gave it 3 out of 5 stars and wrote, "Malli Pelli surpasses the expectations it sets, surprising its viewers with sincerity on one end and unabashed glee on the other.

"[22] Avad Mohammad of OTTplay gave it 3 out of 5 stars and wrote, "MS Raju has neatly put his point across that love can be felt at any age in life.

Raju managed to create some good moments, but the authenticity factor remains unknown as the movie is based on the real lives of Naresh and Pavitra.

[26] Kiran Kumar of News18 Telugu gave it 2.25 out of 5 stars and stated, "The life of Naresh is the subject of the controversial film Malli Pelli.