[1] Awarding this album three stars from HM Magazine, Tim Hallila states, "A refreshingly tight sound".

"[3] Giving the album four stars at Jesus Freak Hideout, Scott Fryberger describes, "Milestone shows that Facedown Records still has game.

"[6] Steven Cosand, awarding the album five stars from Indie Vision Music, says, "There is something so youthful and refreshing about this band.

Milestone stands out lyrically and musically in comparison to recent releases from both secular and Christian bands.

Gideon is hands down the band that has renewed my faith in Christian hardcore.