Nazareth Area High School has also appeared on the College Boards Advanced Placement Honor Roll for four consecutive years.

The original construction of the building consisted of two floors of academic classrooms with an auditorium, a gym, and a large cafeteria.

In addition to new classrooms, the addition included of the Sharon L. Adams Library and Media Center, expanded the cafeteria to nearly four times its original size, and added onto the current gym, doubling the size while also adding a lower level which housed a fitness room and coach's offices.

In 1998, the school experienced a mold problem which destroyed most of the old ceilings in the original building while causing the lead paint in the 1971 addition to chip faster than expected.

The music wing contains an instrument storage facility, practice rooms, offices, and classrooms that can hold in excess of 200 students at a time.

Their most recent accomplishment includes winning the Cavalcade of Bands Yankee open-class championships in November 2024 at Dallastown Area High School.