[8] In March 2009, the school debuted the musical The Wedding Singer as the first amateur performance of the show in New Jersey.

[14] The Point Pleasant Beach High School Garnet Gulls[2] compete in Division B Central of the Shore Conference, an athletic conference comprised of public and private high schools in Monmouth and Ocean counties along the Jersey Shore.

[3][15] The league operates under the jurisdiction of the New Jersey State Interscholastic Athletic Association (NJSIAA).

These co-op programs operate under agreements scheduled to expire at the end of the 2023–24 school year.

[24] The 2008 girls' tennis team won the Central Jersey Group I state sectional title with a 3–2 win over Highland Park High School.

[29] The 2011-12 boys' soccer team won the NJSIAA Central Jersey Group I sectional title, the program's first, with a 1–0 over Burlington City High School and finishing the season with a record of 13-8-1.

[30][31] The girls' basketball team won the Group I state championship in 2013, defeating Bloomfield Tech High School by a score of 56-54 in the tournament final played at the Pine Belt Arena.

[34] The team won the Group I title in 2013 with a 43-29 win against Jonathan Dayton High School in the finals played at the Rutgers Athletic Center.

They also won their fourth straight divisional title and were Central Jersey Group 1 finalists.

[42] The 2015-16 wrestling team defeated Manville High School 37–25 to win the Central Jersey Group I state sectional title, the first in the program's history.