[9] During the 2014–15 school year, the mascots were Indian XLVII, Princess XLVI, Super Maroon XXXVII, and Spirit XVI.

[9] The original Toms River High School graduated its first class in 1891 and the current building opened for students in 1951.

[21][22][23] The girls spring track team won the Group IV state championship in 1976 (as co-champion with Toms River High School North).

[25] The 1978 team defeated Cherry Hill High School East by a score of 16–6 to win the South Jersey Group IV state sectional championship.

[26] After Eastern Regional High School came back with a late touchdown to tie the game at 14–14 in regulation, the 1983 team won the South Jersey Group III sectional title by a score of 17–14 with an overtime field goal.

[27] In 2015, the team won the South Jersey Group V title with a 14–7 win against Williamstown High School in the tournament final.

[29] In 2024, Toms River South lost by a score 41–0, the team's 24th loss in the previous 31 meetings of the schools, to bring the overall record to 26–26–1.

[33] With a three-run home run from Todd Frazier, the team won the Group III title by a score of 9–4 against Cranford in the championship game to finish the season with a 24–4 record.

[36] In 2009, the boys' soccer team upset Toms River High School North with a 4–3 overtime win in the state semifinals and went on to win the Group IV state championship for the first time in program history, with a 1–0 victory over Clifton High School in the final game of the tournament to finish the season with an 18–5–2 record.