At the Conference of Carthage of 411, which saw the Catholic and Donatists of Roman North Africa debate together.
The records of the Council of Carthage show that the town was represented by the Donatist Cresconius, who reported that there was no Catholic bishop in his diocese.
The proceedings of the conference tell, however, that Auronio of Macomades, who was a fervent Catholic, answered Cresconius saying that Pudenziana had a Catholic bishop named Memmiano and that he had succeeded another bishop with the same name, but that both were now dead.
Auronio of Macomades also accused Cresconi of having destroyed four Catholic basilicas.
In 591, Gregory the Great ordered Bishop Colombo of Nicives to convene a council to judge the work of Massimiano of Pudenziana, accused by his deacons of being bribed by donatists.