Before the formation of Rarity, Learn, Pasquale, Woods, and Stojsavljevic formed the easycore band Safe and Sound.
After the band was displeased with its musical direction, they disbanded and formed the pop punk group Face Value, which garnered attention from Good Fight and Rise Records.
The band announced that they signed to Rise Records on February 18, 2015 and released their debut EP, Alive In Your Eyes, for free streaming and download.
[5] The group released the single "Orchid", featuring A Sight For Sewn Eyes vocalist Joshua Hanusiak on March 30, 2016.
[6] The band recorded their debut studio album, I Couldn't Be Weaker, over the course of a year throughout 2015 with producer Seth Henderson in Indiana.
[8] Silverstein announced their headlining U.S. winter tour with special guests Rarity, Being As An Ocean, Emarosa, and Coldrain, which took place from February 29 to March 31, 2016.
On March 14th Trophy Eyes announced that they were going on tour in the United States with support from Rarity and House & Home.
[1] In an interview with Alternative Press, Woods revealed that the band was heavily influenced by pop punk and Counterparts.