[13] On April 24, 2014, The Story So Far announced they would be releasing Songs Of, an acoustic EP on June 17 through Pure Noise.

On January 5, 2015, a video titled "The Story So Far Album Teaser #1" was uploaded on the band's official YouTube channel.

[22] In efforts to promote the album, the band embarked on a European tour with supporting acts from Citizen and All Get Out.

[26][27] On May 31, 2022, bassist Kelen Capener announced on his Twitter page that he was no longer a member of the band.

[28] Capener was not officially replaced, with drummer Ryan Torf overtaking bass duties in studio and former Man Overboard bassist Nik Bruzzese joining the band in a touring capacity.

In 2022, The Story So Far expanded to a live sextet for the first time in their history, with Torf moving to rhythm guitar.

Set Your Goals drummer Mike Ambrose also joined the band as a touring musician.

In early 2023, guitarist Kevin Geyer alleged on the Two Week Notice podcast that the band were "contractually obligated" to release new music ahead of their tour in support of Blink-182.

With their fourth album, Proper Dose (2018), marking a departure from pop punk and saw the band incorporating indie rock into their sound.