He attended Braden River High School and played tight end there, recording 26 receptions for 470 yards and two touchdowns as a senior.

He was a first-team all-district and all-area selection at tight end, and also served as the team's punter, having an average of 45 yards-per-punt.

As a sophomore in 2018, Neuzil started all 13 games as a left guard and was selected second-team all-conference by Pro Football Focus (PFF).

[10] After spending the entire 2021 season on the practice squad, Neuzil signed a future contract with Atlanta in January 2022.

[12] Neuzil was elevated to the active roster for the Falcons' week nine game against the Los Angeles Chargers, and made his NFL debut in the 17–20 loss, appearing on four special teams snaps.