It mainly played in Eccellenza Abruzzo and Promozione, but on several occasions such as the 2002/2003 season and the 2006/2007 season, it came close to getting promotion to Serie D. Notaresco Calcio won the Coppa Dilettanti Abruzzo two times, in 1999 and in 2001.

In 2018, in accordance with Notaresco's mayor (Diego Di Bonaventura), the club San Nicolò Calcio (founded in 1968 as “A.C.

San Nicolò”, in the 2010–11 season won the Eccellenza Abruzzo, obtaining promotion to Serie D. Its ascent started in Prima Categoria in the 2002–03 season) and was relocated to Notaresco and acquired the old club’s sport title; changing its name to S.N.

In 2022, the club rechanged its name to Notaresco Calcio 1924, its original name.

The team's mascot is a bull, matching the Notaresco municipality coat of arms.