During this time Chad experiences what he believes to be a psychic vision of the Kysers and their Satanic practices; however, the group's investigations discover little on the property.

Later that night Floyd uses the group's monitoring equipment to spy on Chad and Gwen having sex, during which time he sees an unknown person watching them as well.

As the night progresses the group discovers the body of the bank employee that hired Nancy, forcing them to realize that there is something at the house.

Nancy and Gwen both go back into the house to rescue him and in the process discover the killers' lair, which is filled with children's toys.

Filming for Saturday Morning Mystery took place in Austin, Texas, with the script being written to fit the house the movie was set in.

[10][11] Shock Till You Drop praised Paul Gordon's acting but panned the film overall, stating it didn't live up to its potential.

[14] The Hollywood Reporter panned the film, writing that "the entire project has the appearance of messy, hasty planning" and that "performances shade more toward awkward than knowing, while production quality is variable".