The team consisted of Captain Atom, Blue Beetle, the Question and Nightshade.
A revised team made up of existing Americomics characters Captain Paragon, Nightveil, Stardust, Commando D, and Scarlet Scorpion would appear in Captain Paragon and the Sentinels of Justice #1–3 (1985–86), the title would change to Sentinels of Justice with #4 (the indicia would still state Captain Paragon and the Sentinels of Justice), it would last until issue #6 (1986).
The team concept was quickly revised, with a roster of Charlton characters.
After AC received news that the series was cancelled, Bill Black returned to his original plan for a team made up of existing Americomics characters.
A relaunch of the team took place in Femforce #59 with members being from the Vault of Heroes project.