In 2003, Jason Ciolli (guitar) joined the band, and the next year Ryan Loerke took over on drums.
With the help of Los Angeles–based Freeze Management, Stutterfly made a deal with Madonna's Maverick Records in the summer of 2004,[3] and later toured with fellow labelmates Story of the Year.
Stutterfly was dropped from Maverick, with lead singer Chris Stickney leaving the band amicably in August 2007.
Former members of the band including Byron, Chase, Ciolli and Loerke continued to work together under the Secret and Whisper.
Chase and Loerke now play in Shreddy Krueger together along with fellow Secret and Whisper member David Ecker.