Julia C. Thorne and Julia Morizawa co-starred alongside Burgon since the series' launch, with Benjamin Noble, Torgny G. Aanderaa, Jordan Cobb, Erin King, and Hemi Yeroham later joining the main cast.

[1][2][3][4] The series also has material made available only to supporters on Patreon, including several exclusive episodes and two prequel miniseries, The Alvina Chronicles and The Arthur Archives.

"[9] Natalie Zutter wrote on Tor.com that the podcast is like a "comforting mug of cocoa to curl your hands around.

"[10] Sean Keeley wrote in The Comeback that the podcast has an "old-timey tone and intriguing premise.

"[11] Sarah Hemming wrote in the Financial Times that "This droll black comedy is best consumed with a cup of cocoa.