The Best Thing Ever's original lineup consisted of Noah Britton, Alex Billig, Jennifer Page, and Emilyn Brodsky.
On May 1, 2006, Britton, Billig, and Page officially revived The Best Thing Ever moniker before embarking on The Bathroom Tour.
For twelve straight days, The Best Thing Ever invaded bathrooms across New England to perform their music for unsuspecting audiences.
[6] In the summer of 2007, the band reunited for The Surprise Tour, playing exclusively unbooked shows all over the country with acts including Andrew Bird and Gravy Train!!!!.
Venues included the Kansas Barbed Wire Museum, the Mall of America, Corn Palace, and Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, where they put up their own exhibit as inductees for the class of 2007.