The club are members of the Mid-Sussex League Division One and play at the Verdayne Sports Ground.

[3] The club won the league in 2005–06 but were not promoted to the Premier Division due to ground grading.

[4] In the same season, the club competed in the FA Cup for the first time.

[5] Warlingham played their homes games at Whyteleafe's home ground at Church Road, Whyteleafe from the 2010–11 season until 2013 when they moved back to their own unfloodlit ground.

The club now uses Church Lane in Warlingham for all its sides, but its first team had to play at Whyteleafe's home ground so they could continue to participate in the Combined Counties League.