was formed in 1946, replacing another club, Whyteleafe Albion, which had existed before World War II.

In 1999, they reached the First Round Proper of the FA Cup for the first time in their history and held Chester City to a 0–0 draw before losing the replay.

[3] Ahead of the 2021–22 season, Whyteleafe announced that they had withdrawn from the Isthmian League, following the loss of their Church Road ground.

[4] In August 2021, a 'phoenix' club named AFC Whyteleafe was formed, securing a deal on Church Road.

The site of Church Road was formerly farmland, and the farm's existing buildings were converted into the clubhouse and dressing rooms.