Sports teams are called the Warriors, and they compete in the Ohio High School Athletic Association as a member of the Eastern Buckeye Conference.

[5] West Branch entered the playoffs with an undefeated record of 10–0 in the 1994 season and had clinched an NBC league title.

After a 21–7 deficit in the first half, the Warriors charged back with 3 consecutive touchdowns leading them to a 31–28 victory and a berth in the state finals.

West Branch's football program maintains a rivalry with Salem High School, located about 9 miles (14 km) away.

This win, coupled with a perfect regular season, started a run through the playoffs which ultimately led to a state championship.