[19] In 1999, the soccer team earned the South, Group III sectional title with a 2–0 win against Moorestown High School.

[20] In 2012, the soccer team won the South Jersey Group II sectional title with a 4–1 win in penalty kicks after a 2–2 tie in the tournament final against Cinnaminson High School.

[27] The wrestling team took the South Jersey, Group III sectional title in 2000 with a 37–23 win in the tournament final against Oakcrest High School.

[citation needed] The 1996 softball team finished the season with a 24–6 record after winning the Group II state championship.

[31] The football team won the South, Group II state sectional championship in 2002 edging Buena Regional High School 21–20 in the tournament final.

[34][35] The Eagles went on to win the Group II state championship a fourth time in 2007 with a 31–17 victory over Point Pleasant Boro High School.

[39] The baseball team won the Group II state championship in 2016, defeating Parsippany High School by a score of 2–1 in the tournament final.

However WDMB's consecutive winning streak was broken in 2018 by the Huntingtown Marching Band, who won first place by 0.25 points.