[5] The website aims to be "uninhibited" and feature "taboo fantasies", with a representative claiming that "It doesn’t matter if you like studs with big dicks, blondes with big tits, young hunks, cute teens or all of the above — WhyNotBi has something for everyone", including bisexual threesomes and orgies, spouse swapping, boyfriend sharing, and cuckoldry.

Gay porn actors including Wesley Woods, Jackson Trainor, Thyle Knoxx, and Justin Matthews have made their first bisexual scenes on WhyNotBi.

[7][8] The website has been praised for its diversity for featuring gay, bisexual, heterosexual, and transgender content in its scenes.

[9] WhyNotBi's film Free For All won "Best Bi Sex Scene" at the 2020 GayVN Awards.

[10] In 2021, WhyNotBi's film The Elevator Goes Both Ways won "Best Bi Sex Scene" at the GayVN Awards.