[2][4][5] In 2002 the venue was renamed The Amish and Mennonite Heritage Center to reflect its mission as a cultural hub.

[6][7] That same year, the Pioneer Barn exhibit was built to house a restored Conestoga wagon, buggies, and farm equipment.

[14] Inspiration for the painting came in 1978 when an Amish blacksmith told Heinz, "I wish there was some place in the area that people could go and find out why we live the way we do.

[9][8] The center incorporates a display area for exhibits of various Anabaptist Christian denominations' head coverings; historical information about the international Amish and Mennonite newspaper The Budget; treatments of the Ausbund, a 1564 hymnal which is the oldest in continuous use; Martyrs Mirror and the Froschauer Bible; along with other displays.

[4] In 2021, the Zollikon Institute of Holmes County took up residence in the Center, offering contemporary skills content in an Anabaptist context.