[5][6] Program director Ron Parker was inducted into the Wisconsin High School Theatre Hall of Fame in 2011.

In the 2007–08 season, the boys' team went to the state tournament for the first time, before losing to Edgewood High School of the Sacred Heart in the semifinals.

[18] During its 2006-2007 inaugural season, the Appleton United Women's hockey team won sectionals and went to the state tournament, eventually defeating Chippewa Falls 4–2 in the championship game.

[citation needed] In 2009, the performance team won first place in the National Dance Association's Medium Poms division.

[22] During the 2008 soccer season, the varsity team went to the state tournament, where they lost to Divine Savior Holy Angels High School.

[24] The team completed a perfect season in 2012 (34-0) by defeating Burlington to claim their first boys' volleyball state championship.