Alter appointed Monsignor Edward A. McCarthy and Brother Paul Sibbing, S.M., to supervise the planning and construction of a new high school near Montgomery, Ohio.

[8] Starting with the freshman class of 1999, Moeller High School adopted a new laptop program.

Common uses for the laptops include writing papers, doing research (using both the Internet and the school's reference systems), and presenting projects.

Starting with the class of 2018, students began leasing Tablet PCs rather than standard laptops, allowing them to take notes within OneNote without needing to type.

In 2008, The Crusader won First Place[clarification needed], the second-highest honor a high school newspaper can receive from the American Scholastic Press Association.

Selected works for publication are chosen by Moeller's Creative Writing Club, who also edit and publish the journal each year.

[12] The Greater Catholic League, more commonly known as the GCL, is often considered one of the premier high school conferences in the country.

In 2004, led by five starters who would go on to play NCAA Division I basketball, Moeller reached as high as the top 10 in USA Today's national poll.

[citation needed] The 2007 title went to the second team in Ohio high school boys' volleyball history to go undefeated.