In 2005, FC Indiana became the second North American women's team ever to win a league and cup double, capturing the WPSL national championship and the USASA Women's Open national championship (the Carolina Courage of the former Women's United Soccer Association [WUSA] won the Founder's Cup and WUSA league title in 2002).

FC Indiana won the 2005 WPSL title, having defeated host New England Mutiny 4–0 in the 2005 semifinals and the California Storm 5–4 (featuring internationals Brandi Chastain, Leslie Osborne and Sissi) in the 2005 finals.

In October 2007, FC Indiana joined the W-League, consistently winning their division before returning to the WPSL for the 2011 season.

Indiana joined the newly formed Midwest Conference of United Women's Soccer as an expansion team.

[3] Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.