The AlleyCats compete in the Ultimate Frisbee Association (UFA) as a member of the Central Division.

In their first year, the AlleyCats competed in the league championship, losing to the Philadelphia Spinners.

The AlleyCats play at Westfield's Grand Park Sports Campus indoor facility.

The team has called Grand Park home since midway through the 2018 season.

Historic Indianapolis AlleyCats players include, Cameron Brock (all time leading goal scorer in league history), Travis Carpenter, Rick Gross, Jake Fella, Levi Jacobs, Nick Hutton, Keenan Plew, Kyle Cox, Lucas Coniaris and Brody Smith.