[6] As a Senior, Smith scored 18 goals with 8 assists[7] earning Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference Offensive MVP during his final seasons.

[10] He left the Dutch Lions as their all-time leader in goals, assists, and points with twelve, eight and thirty-two respectively, as well having set their season records in those categories in 2015.

Although he didn't score in regulation time during any of the USL Cup matches, he converted the first shot of the penalty shoot-out in the Eastern Conference final against New York Red Bulls II.

Although he didn't score in regulation time during any of the USL Cup matches, he converted the first shot of the penalty shoot-out in the Eastern Conference final against New York Red Bulls II.

[20][21] Smith had his contract renewed with Louisville[22] and he made his season debut on March 17 against USL expansion side Nashville SC.

[28] On December 19, 2018, Smith moved to Major League Soccer side Orlando City, reuniting him with head coach James O'Connor who had left Louisville earlier in the year.

[29] Smith made his first appearance for the club in the first match of the 2019 season when he started in a 2–2 draw against New York City FC on March 2 before he was taken off as a 69th-minute substitute for Dom Dwyer.

[32] On May 27, 2022, Smith was fined by the MLS Disciplinary Committee for his role in a confrontation between Orlando City and Austin FC players following a match between them five days earlier.