Rhodes was selected three times to the All-Colonial Athletic Association First Team and was the only Division I-AA player named to the watch list for the 2015 Butkus Award.
[8] During the off-season, the Colts converted Rhodes to a new position, that of long snapper for punts and kickoffs.
[8] Rhodes successfully adapted to his new role and on August 28, 2017, was named the Colts' full-time long snapper after winning a training camp competition against rookie Thomas Hennessy.
Rhodes also became the first Indianapolis long snapper named to the Pro Bowl since Matt Overton in 2013.
[12] On September 8, 2023, Rhodes signed a four-year, $6.465 million contract extension with the Colts, once again making him the highest-paid long snapper in the league.