During this time, an independent attempt to build a second area mall in downtown failed.

[13] Value City would close in March 2008, with Burlington Coat Factory announced as its replacement in May.

[34] The mall lost power in late August 2018 due to owner not paying its PPL electric bill, but reopened the next day.

[39][40] Dick's Sporting Goods moved from the mall to the Lycoming Crossing Shopping Center in late 2021.

[46] In mid-February 2023, ownership gave notices to vacate to the remaining interior stores except for Books-A-Million and Burlington.

[3][48] The mall in May 2023 was again placed up for sheriff's sale by the Lycoming County Water and Sewer Authority due to unpaid bills.

The arch was purchased by board members from Hess's and Crown American, with its dedication being in November 1978.