[7] After hitting .307/.347/.453 with eight home runs, Arcia was named the Brewers Minor League Player of the Year for 2015.

Arcia began the 2016 season with the Colorado Springs Sky Sox of the Class AAA Pacific Coast League.

[12] He was recalled on July 26 and rebounded to finish the season hitting .236/.268/.307 with 3 homers and 30 RBIs, including two walk-off singles.

In Game 3 of the 2018 NLDS against the Colorado Rockies, he homered off of Wade Davis to extend the Brewers' lead in their eventual series-clinching 6-0 victory.

[15] On April 6, 2021, the Brewers traded Arcia to the Atlanta Braves for Patrick Weigel and Chad Sobotka.

[16] Arcia and Sean Newcomb were optioned to Gwinnett on July 31, as trade acquisitions Jorge Soler and Richard Rodríguez joined the team.

[23] In spring training in 2023, Arcia competed against Vaughn Grissom and Braden Shewmake for the starting shortstop job.

[24] On Opening Day, Arcia and the Braves agreed to a three-year contract extension worth $7.3 million.