While it was initially to be a portal/repository of The Philippine Star and its sister publications (Pilipino Star Ngayon, PM: Pang Masa, The Freeman, and Banat), the website began publishing its own news articles independently of the newspaper itself with its own editorial team.
[3][2] On December 16, 2022, The Star editorial-in-chief Ana Paminutan wrote her column entitled "Scammers", contains a blind item about someone who misrepresenting or posing as "editor-in-chief" of the newspaper itself on the website.
[2] The column has been sparked on Twitter among netizens, including editorial staff of the Philstar website.
Camille Diola, editorial head of Philstar Global, responded to Pamintuan's claim in her tweet that she has never misrepresented herself under the "editorial-in-chief" label through a subject of misinformation.
Some staff members of the Philstar Global posted a video on YouTube clarifying differences between the Star newspaper and Philstar online in terms of independent news publishing.