[29] In 2009, six members of the Senior class were named recipients of the Edward J. Bloustein Distinguished Scholar award.
The 1981 team was the Central Jersey Group III champion, defeating Asbury Park High School by a score of 35–0 in the finals to finish 11–0.
[38] With a 9–0 win in the tournament final, the 1988 team won the Central Jersey Group II sectional title and finished the season at 9–2.
[40] The team won the Central Jersey Group I state title in 2015 with a 56–28 win against Palmyra High School.
[41] The school has had a longstanding football rivalry with Point Pleasant Beach High School, and leads the series with an overall record of 30-12 through the 2017 season, including the games in which the two teams faced each other in the Central Jersey Group I championship game in both 2013 and 2014.
[42] The wrestling team won its first sectional championship and 8th overall divisional championship in 2019 with a 45–19 win over rival Point Pleasant Beach in the Central Jersey Group I finals[43][44][45] Nine wrestlers on that team also qualified for the region 5 tournament and four wrestlers were crowned as district champions [46] including Jack Maida who would go on to finish 6th in the state at 106 lbs and Al De Santis who would place 7th in the state the following year at 138 lbs.
Since 2010, the team has crowned 12 district champions including Luke Bush, Derek Arnette, Austin Cannon, Jack Maida, Taylor Sousa, Mike McGhee and Al De Santis.
[53] In 2007, the field hockey team won the North II, Group I state sectional championship with a 2–1 win over Pingry School in the tournament final.
[54] The 1988 softball team finished the season with a record of 31-2 after winning the Group II state title, defeating Whippany Park High School by a score of 2–0 on a two-hitter in the championship game.
[59] The 1993 team defeated defending-champion Rutherford High School by a score of 5–1 in the tournament final to finish the season 23–5.
The girls lacrosse won the 2007 South, Group I state sectional championship, edging Holy Cross High School 10–9 in the tournament final.
[68] Shore Players, the Shore Regional theatre department, has focused mainly on musicals and has performed productions such as West Side Story, Fiddler on the Roof, Grease, Seussical, Evita, one of their largest productions yet, Beauty and the Beast (which won several Count Basie Awards, including Overall Musical, Outstanding Choreography, Set Design and Chorus), Over Here!, and Gypsy (in which a few students won Count Basie and Papermill Awards).
The $12.1 million budget for the 2006–07 school year failed to pass after it was turned down by voters in Oceanport and Sea Bright.
[70] By a more than 5–2 margin, voters in all four districts rejected a $49.8 million bond referendum that would have been used for renovations to the school building.
[72] Voters rejected the district's $11.1 million budget for 2003–04, which was ultimately cut by $161,000 by the New Jersey Commissioner of Education.
[88][89] Seats on the board of education are allocated based on the population of the constituent municipalities, with four assigned to West Long Branch, three to Oceanport, and one each from Monmouth Beach and Sea Bright.