The team competes in the North Atlantic West conference of the National Club Baseball Association.

The current team captured a division title in the 2022-23 season while finishing runner-up in the New England Regional.

Syracuse played their home games on Lew Carr Field, named after the Orangemen's coach from 1910 to 1942, compiling a 275–268 record.

They then defeated Western Michigan 6–0, before being eliminated by eventual tournament runner-up Oklahoma State 8–0.

The 1961 Syracuse baseball team included two future major league pitchers, Dave Giusti and Billy Connors, and four members of the 1959 NCAA championship football team: Dave Sarette, Billy Canon, Dick Easterly, and Bob Lelli.