John Wright, the founding principal, remained at Timber Creek until 2012 when he became the executive area director for the school system's East Learning Community.

[2] Timber Creek has won state championships in baseball (2017), bowling (2006, boys and girls), volleyball (2008 Florida High School Athletic Association),[3] and cheerleading (2009, 2010, 2012 and 2013).

[4] In addition to winning the 2015 Florida State Championship and competing in the World Championship, the VEX Robotics team has won the following awards:[5] The programming team at Timber Creek High School competes in contests modeled after the International Collegiate Programming Contest.

It is intended to prepare the students for the AP courses that they will take in the future by increasing rigor and moving at the faster pace than normal honors classes.

[11] Recently, they won the 2021 FMBC State Championship with their show The Hill We Climb, based on the Poem by Amanda Gorman.