[19] The school was the Group III winner of the 2019-20 ShopRite Cup, which recognizes athletic achievement across all interscholastic sports.

[22] In 1979, the team won its second consecutive Group III championship with a 2–1 win against Dwight Morrow, to finish the season with a record of 21-4-1.

In 2009, displays were erected and a Hall of Fame established honoring the overall success of WHS soccer teams.

[27] In front of a championship-game crowd of 9,000, the 1983 team won the Central Jersey Group III title with a 21–3 win against Ocean Township High School to finish the season with an 11–0 record.

[28] The team won the 2016 South Jersey Group III state sectional championship, defeating reigning four-time champion Delsea Regional High School by a score of 20–7 in the tournament final.

[32] The team won the Group III title in 2019 with a 10–2 win against West Morris Central High School.

[34] In 2008, the field hockey team won the Group III title with a 1–0 win on a second-half goal against Holmdel in the tournament finals[35][36] and continued to the Tournament of Champions, losing to Eastern Regional High School by 3–1 in the championship game to finish the season 21–2.

[41] The softball team won the 2007 Central, Group III state sectional championship with a 6–5 win over Monroe Township High School.

[43] The 2007 girls' tennis team won the Central Jersey, Group III state sectional championship with a 3–2 win over Princeton High School in the tournament final.

[citation needed] In 2008, the Wall High School golf team won the South-Central Jersey Group III Tournament.

[citation needed] The Wall lacrosse team had its first season in 2006 and won the Shore Conference division championships in both 2008 and 2011.

[47] The ice hockey team made its first appearance in the New Jersey Public B state championship in 2017, losing to Glen Rock High School by a score of 9–1 in the tournament final.

[48] In 2015, former district superintendent James Habel was sentenced to five years in prison, forfeiture of his pension and the loss of his ability to work in a public sector job in the state, after his conviction on charges of official misconduct.

Students noted that political apparel for other politicians (Reagan-Bush and Barack Obama) were included in the current and past yearbooks.