The club play in the Northern Premier League Midlands Division, the eighth tier of English football.

Initially they played on Pitchcroft on an enclosed area called Severn Terrace (behind the modern day Swan Theatre).

In 1924–25 they won the league for the first time, and the following season reached the FA Cup first round again, losing 2–0 to Kettering Town in a second replay at St Andrew's.

The club won back-to-back league titles in 1928–29 and 1929–30, also reaching the FA Cup first round in the former, losing 3–1 at Walsall.

Having beaten Sandbach Ramblers 4–1, City progressed to the last eight where a 2–0 away defeat followed a goalless draw against South Shields ended their cup run.

The club remained in the Southern League Premier Division until 2004, when a fifth-placed finish earned them a place in the newly established Conference North.

City secured a replay at Aggborough after a 1–1 draw, in which Daniel Nti equalised immediately after half-time with a strike into the roof of the net in front of the 2,200 travelling fans.

The replay also finished 1–1 and, some 21⁄2 hours after kick-off, Scunthorpe won 14–13 on penalties, setting a record for the longest shoot-out in FA Cup history.

[6] The 2023–24 season saw Worcester promoted from the Hellenic Football League as champions, as well as reaching the semi-finals of the FA Vase.

In late 2019 it was announced that City would be returning to Worcester for the start of the 2020–21 season and playing at the Worcestershire FA headquarters at Claines Lane.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.