The area now comprising Benton Park proper was first used as the City Cemetery, from 1842–1865.

[3] Those buried in the cemetery were relocated in 1865, and the neighborhood was created on June 25, 1866, by city ordinance.

Noted horticulturist Edward F. Krausnick landscaped the park, incorporating a greenhouse, a footbridge, and two ponds.

The park was used for botanical instruction and community activities and today is a popular recreational area.

The caves maintain a constant 55 degree temperature that is ideal for beer storage.