The lyrics were written by Daniel Bashiel Warner (1815–1880), who later became the third president of Liberia, and the music was composed by Olmstead Luca (1826–1869).

On 22 July 1974, the Legislature of Liberia passed an act giving authorization to the president to establish a commission to give consideration to possible changes to a number of national symbols, including "All Hail, Liberia, Hail!"

President William Tolbert appointed 51 members to the Commission on National Unity.

The commission sought to reexamine the symbols and remove divisive aspects of them.

In joy and gladness With our hearts united, We'll shout the freedom Of a race benighted,

With heart and hand Our country's cause defending We'll meet the foe With valor unpretending.