The club returned the following season but once again disappeared in 1930 and remained absent until 1936 when they were founder members of the newly organised Central Wales League.

The club spent five years in the top flight of Welsh football, the League of Wales, with a best finish of 12th, before being relegated in 2002.

[2] During this period, the club signed the Brazilian player Jose Ricardo Rodrigues Ferreira (known as "Junior").

[3] Rhayader Town folded in July 2006 and resigned from the Spar Mid Wales League.

However, citing the difficulties of obtaining enough players to travel distances to matches, the club resigned from the league in July 2017 before the 2017–18 season commenced.