The company announced plans to operate at Pike Place Market in 2013, occupying the space which previously housed Chez Shea.

[4][5] The business Storyville's third coffee shop opened in Queen Anne in 2014.

[citation needed] During 2013–2014, a writer for The Stranger asked readers not to support the company because of the author's claim of a connection to the Mars Hill Church.

[10][11] Cheyenne Buckingham selected Storyville for Washington in Eat This, Not That's 2019 overview of the best coffee shops in each U.S.

[13] USA Today named Storyville Coffee a top ten roaster in the U.S.[14]